Standard II — Integrity of Capital Markets Module 1 · 15-20% Weight Lesson 064

📖 Standards I-V 中测复习

Standards I-V Mid-Assessment Review


一、五大标准速览表

标准 核心主题 关键词
Standard I 职业操守(Professionalism) 守法、独立客观、不误导、端正行为
Standard II 资本市场诚信(Capital Markets) 禁止内幕交易、禁止市场操纵
Standard III 对客户的责任(Duties to Clients) 忠诚审慎、公平对待、适当性、保密
Standard IV 对雇主的责任(Duties to Employers) 忠诚、额外报酬披露、监督责任
Standard V 投资分析(Investment Analysis) 勤勉有据、充分沟通、记录保留

二、Standard I:职业操守 — 关键回顾

I(A) 知法守法

知道法律 → 遵守法律 → 如果 CFA 准则更严 → 遵守 CFA 准则
                                    → 如果法律更严 → 遵守法律
→ 知道违规 → 必须报告 → 脱离违规环境
要点 说明
最严标准适用 在 CFA 准则和适用法律之间,遵守更严格的那个
知情不报 知道违规而不报告=自身违规
脱离义务 无法阻止违规时,必须脱离(dissociate)
跨境问题 向合规部门或法律顾问寻求指导

I(B) 独立性与客观性

  • 不接受可能影响独立判断的礼物、好处
  • 发行方付费的研究必须披露
  • 发行人压力不得影响评级或建议
  • 公司内部压力(投行施压研究部)同样适用

I(C) 不误导(Misrepresentation)

  • 不得故意虚假陈述
  • 不得遗漏重大信息(omission = misrepresentation)
  • 不得抄袭(plagiarism)
  • 引用必须标注出处

I(D) 不当行为(Misconduct)

  • 涉及欺诈、欺骗等不诚实行为
  • 影响职业诚信的行为
  • 注意:并非所有违法行为都是 I(D) 违规——必须与职业诚信相关

三、Standard II:资本市场诚信 — 关键回顾

II(A) 重大非公开信息(MNPI)

信息的判断流程:
信息是否重大?→ 理性投资者是否会认为重要
    │
信息是否非公开?→ 是否已向市场广泛传播
    │
如果都是 → 这是 MNPI → 不得交易或促使他人交易
    │                → 可以做:尽力促使信息公开
概念 判断标准
重大性(Materiality) 合理投资者在作出投资决策时会认为重要
非公开性(Nonpublic) 信息尚未向市场广泛传播
马赛克理论(Mosaic Theory) 将公开信息+非重大非公开信息拼成结论 = 合法分析
防火墙(Firewall) 限制 MNPI 在内部分享的制度和程序

II(B) 市场操纵

  • 禁止扭曲价格或制造虚假交易量
  • 禁止散布虚假谣言影响市场
  • 禁止通过虚假交易制造活跃假象(wash trading)
  • 注意区分合法交易策略与操纵行为

四、Standard III:对客户的责任 — 关键回顾

III(A) 忠诚、审慎、关怀

客户利益第一
    │
    ├── 受托责任:客户的依赖程度越高,责任越重
    ├── 软美元:必须直接惠及客户
    └── 投票代理权:必须为客户利益行使

III(B) 公平对待

  • 不得在客户之间进行不公平的分配
  • 交易分配:按比例(pro-rata)是最佳实践
  • IPO 分配:特别敏感,不能优待某些客户
  • 投资建议的传播:所有客户应同时或尽可能接近地获得

III(C) 适当性(Suitability)

产品推荐 → 是否符合客户的:
    ├── IPS(投资政策声明)
    ├── 风险承受能力
    ├── 投资目标和限制
    ├── 财务状况
    └── 投资经验和知识

III(D) 业绩展示

  • 必须公平、准确、完整地展示投资业绩
  • 不得选择性展示有利期间
  • 必须遵守 GIPS(如果适用)
  • 模拟业绩必须明确标注

III(E) 保密

  • 客户信息 = 机密
  • 即使离职,保密义务继续
  • 例外:法律要求披露、客户书面同意、CFA 协会调查

五、Standard IV:对雇主的责任 — 关键回顾

IV(A) 忠诚

在职期间:
    ├── 不得与雇主竞争
    ├── 不得为个人利益占用雇主机会
    └── 离开时:可以做竞争准备,但不能在离职前实际开始竞争行为

离职后:
    └── 可以使用从雇主获得的技能和经验,但不能带走雇主财产

IV(B) 额外报酬

  • 来自第三方的与工作相关的报酬 → 必须获得雇主书面同意
  • 客户给的礼物 → 区分服务费(需披露)和小额象征性礼物
  • 事前披露 > 事后披露

IV(C) 监督责任

  • 监督者有责任防止下属违规
  • 必须建立和执行合规程序
  • 发现违规必须采取行动
  • 不可简单"不知道"来免责

六、Standard V:投资分析与建议 — 关键回顾

(详见 L062 综合复习)

子标准 一句话核心
V(A) 分析必须有合理基础
V(B) 重大变化必须告知客户
V(C) 记录必须保留以待审查

七、跨标准违规辨析(核心题型)

7.1 内幕信息 + 客户义务 = ?

场景 涉及标准
分析师收到 MNPI,在信息公开前为客户交易 II(A) + III(A)
分析师收到 MNPI,告诉客户但自己未交易 II(A) 仍违规(促使他人交易)
合规部得知某员工利用 MNPI,但无所作为 IV(C)(监督失职)
分析师不做交易,但撰写报告暗示 MNPI 信息 II(A) + V(B)

7.2 雇主利益 vs 客户利益

场景 结果
雇主投行部施压分析师给某 IPO 好评 分析师:I(B) 独立性 > IV(A) 雇主忠诚
分析师发现雇主产品不适合客户但仍推荐 III(B)/III(C) 违反 > 对雇主有利
离职前收集客户名单准备新工作 IV(A) 违规(客户名单是雇主财产)

7.3 独立性 + 适当性 + 公平对待

场景 涉及标准
投行客户施压给某股票好评 I(B) 独立性
推荐产品不适合客户风险承受力 III(C) 适当性
给大客户优先推荐再给小客户 III(B) 公平对待

八、中测模拟题(15 题)

Q1. 以下哪个不是判断信息是否"重大"的标准?

A) 合理投资者的决策是否会受到该信息的影响
B) 信息是否可能导致股价大幅变动
C) 信息是否已被公司 CEO 知晓
D) 信息在类似情况下是否过去曾被视为重大


Q2. 马赛克理论的正确理解是:

A) 将公开信息与非重大内幕信息组合分析是合法的
B) 将公开信息与重大内幕信息组合分析是合法的
C) 所有信息组合分析的行为都应禁止
D) 马赛克理论只适用于机构投资者


Q3. 分析师发现雇主的一只推荐股票存在严重财务造假。分析师首先应该:

A) 立即卖出个人持有的该股票
B) 联系监管机构举报
C) 按照公司内部合规程序上报
D) 通知客户立即卖出


Q4. 一个对冲基金经理同时管理两个账户:收费 2/20 的基金和收费 1/10 的专户。他在 IPO 分配时应:

A) 优先分配给费用更高的账户
B) 优先分配给长期合作的客户
C) 按比例公平分配
D) 随机分配即可


Q5. 分析师参加发行方组织的豪华晚宴,价值约 500 美元。正确的处理方式是:

A) 婉拒或自付费用,以保持独立性
B) 接受但向雇主报告
C) 接受并在研报中披露
D) 接受但下一份研报推迟发布


Q6. 离职分析师带走了自己制作的估值模型(用公司电脑和时间完成)。这违反了:

A) IV(A) — 模型是雇主财产
B) V(C) — 记录保留
C) I(C) — 不误导
D) 不违规,因为是个人创作


Q7. 投资经理在客户季度报告中使用选择性数据,只展示盈利交易,不展示亏损交易。这主要违反:

A) III(A) — 忠诚义务
B) III(B) — 公平对待
C) III(D) — 业绩展示
D) V(B) — 客户沟通


Q8. 关于雇主忠诚(IV(A))与客户忠诚(III(A))的关系:

A) 对雇主的忠诚永远优先
B) 对客户的忠诚永远优先
C) 两者平行,发生冲突时客户利益优先
D) 取决于雇佣合同的具体条款


Q9. 分析师从 CFO 处得知公司即将发布盈利预警(尚未公开),分析师应该:

A) 立即将该信息告知所有客户
B) 不交易,但可以暗示客户关注风险
C) 不交易,不传播,报告合规部门并敦促公司尽快公开
D) 卖出个人持股


Q10. 某监督者发现下属存在内幕交易嫌疑,但因为该下属业绩突出而未采取行动。该监督者:

A) 不违规,因为没有亲自交易
B) 不违规,因为不知道是否真的违规
C) 违反 IV(C) 监督责任
D) 仅违反公司内部规章


Q11. 以下哪项不需要雇主书面同意?

A) 接受客户 100 美元餐饮招待
B) 接受第三方支付的额外报酬(与工作相关)
C) 在工作之余从事与雇主竞争的业务
D) 接受发行方支付的「研究赞助」


Q12. GIPS(全球投资业绩标准)属于哪个标准的延伸?

A) III(A)
B) III(C)
C) III(D)
D) V(A)


Q13. 分析师在一份研报中引用了他人的研究但没有注明出处(未作商业使用,仅内部分享)。这:

A) 不违规,因为是内部使用
B) 违反 I(C) — 抄袭(plagiarism)
C) 违反 V(A) — 合理基础
D) 不违规,只要标明"仅供参考"


Q14. 以下哪种情况同时涉及 II(A) 和 III(A)?

A) 分析师选了一只股票但未做充分研究
B) 分析师利用内幕信息为客户交易获利
C) 分析师收取发行方回扣推荐股票
D) 分析师在研究中抄袭他人


Q15. "作为 CFA 持证人,你必须遵守最严格的适用规则。"这个原则的来源是:

A) I(A) 知法守法
B) I(B) 独立性与客观性
C) III(A) 忠诚义务
D) IV(A) 对雇主忠诚


九、答案与解析

  1. C — CEO 是否知晓不是"重大性"的法定判定标准。关键是合理投资者的视角。
  2. A — 马赛克理论的核心:公开信息 + 非重大非公开信息 = 合法分析。
  3. C — 发现雇主产品问题应首先走内部合规渠道;越级举报在合规允许前可能导致自身违规。
  4. C — III(B) 要求公平分配,不能根据费用高低决定分配。
  5. A — 500 美元已超出可接受的合理范围,最佳做法是婉拒或自付。
  6. A — 用公司资源(电脑、工作时间)完成的工作属于雇主财产。
  7. C — 选择性数据展示违反 III(D) 业绩展示的公平完整性要求。
  8. C — 对雇主的忠诚不能凌驾于对客户的忠诚之上。
  9. C — MNPI 的正确处理:不交易、不传播、上报合规、促公开。
  10. C — 监督者对下属违规行为的知情不报是 IV(C) 的直接违规。
  11. A — 小额餐饮招待不触发 IV(B) 书面同意要求。
  12. C — GIPS 是对 III(D) 业绩展示标准的标准化延伸。
  13. B — 抄袭(plagiarism)无论是公开还是内部分享都是 I(C) 违规。
  14. B — 内幕信息 = II(A);为客户交易 = 涉及 III(A) 的受托责任。
  15. A — I(A) 规定了"更严格标准适用"原则。

下一课 L065:Standard VI(A) — 利益冲突披露


1. Five Standards at a Glance

Standard Core Theme Keywords
Standard I Professionalism Know the law, independence, no misrepresentation, integrity
Standard II Integrity of Capital Markets No insider trading, no market manipulation
Standard III Duties to Clients Loyalty/prudence/care, fair dealing, suitability, confidentiality
Standard IV Duties to Employers Loyalty, additional compensation disclosure, supervisory responsibility
Standard V Investment Analysis Diligence with basis, communication, record retention

2. Standard I: Professionalism — Key Review

I(A) Knowledge of the Law

Know the law → Comply with the law → If CFA Code is stricter → Follow CFA Code
                                     → If law is stricter → Follow the law
→ Know of a violation → Must report → Dissociate from the violating environment
Key Point Explanation
Strictest standard applies Between the CFA Code and applicable law, follow whichever is stricter
Knowing and not reporting Knowing of a violation without reporting = own violation
Duty to dissociate When unable to stop a violation, must dissociate
Cross-border issues Seek guidance from compliance or legal counsel

I(B) Independence & Objectivity

  • Do not accept gifts or benefits that could affect independent judgment
  • Issuer-paid research must be disclosed
  • Issuer pressure must not influence ratings or recommendations
  • Internal firm pressure (e.g., investment banking pressuring research) applies equally

I(C) Misrepresentation

  • Must not knowingly make false statements
  • Must not omit material information (omission = misrepresentation)
  • Must not plagiarize
  • Citations must identify sources

I(D) Misconduct

  • Involving fraud, deceit, or dishonest acts
  • Conduct that reflects poorly on professional integrity
  • Note: Not all illegal acts are I(D) violations — must relate to professional integrity

3. Standard II: Integrity of Capital Markets — Key Review

II(A) Material Nonpublic Information (MNPI)

Information assessment flow:
Is the information material? → Would a reasonable investor consider it important
    │
Is the information nonpublic? → Has it been widely disseminated to the market
    │
If both are yes → This is MNPI → Must not trade or cause others to trade
                    │
                    → Permitted action: Make reasonable efforts to achieve public dissemination
Concept Criterion
Materiality A reasonable investor would consider it important in making an investment decision
Nonpublic nature Information has not yet been widely disseminated to the market
Mosaic Theory Combining public info + non-material nonpublic info to reach a conclusion = legitimate analysis
Firewall Procedures and systems limiting internal sharing of MNPI

II(B) Market Manipulation

  • Must not distort prices or create false trading volume
  • Must not spread false rumors to influence the market
  • Must not create a false impression of activity through fictitious trades (wash trading)
  • Must distinguish between legitimate trading strategies and manipulative behavior

4. Standard III: Duties to Clients — Key Review

III(A) Loyalty, Prudence, Care

Client interests first
    │
    ├── Fiduciary duty: The greater the client's reliance, the heavier the duty
    ├── Soft dollars: Must directly benefit the client
    └── Proxy voting: Must be exercised in the client's interest

III(B) Fair Dealing

  • Must not allocate unfairly among clients
  • Trade allocation: Pro-rata is best practice
  • IPO allocation: Particularly sensitive; must not favor certain clients
  • Dissemination of recommendations: All clients should receive them simultaneously or as close as possible

III(C) Suitability

Product recommendation → Does it match the client's:
    ├── IPS (Investment Policy Statement)
    ├── Risk tolerance
    ├── Investment objectives and constraints
    ├── Financial situation
    └── Investment experience and knowledge

III(D) Performance Presentation

  • Must present investment performance fairly, accurately, and completely
  • Must not selectively display favorable periods
  • Must comply with GIPS (if applicable)
  • Simulated performance must be clearly labeled

III(E) Preservation of Confidentiality

  • Client information = confidential
  • Confidentiality obligation continues even after leaving employment
  • Exceptions: Required by law, client's written consent, CFA Institute investigation

5. Standard IV: Duties to Employers — Key Review

IV(A) Loyalty

While employed:
    ├── Must not compete with employer
    ├── Must not appropriate employer opportunities for personal benefit
    └── Upon leaving: May prepare to compete, but may not actually begin competing before departure

After departure:
    └── May use skills and experience gained from employer, but may not take employer property

IV(B) Additional Compensation

  • Work-related compensation from third parties → must obtain employer's written consent
  • Client gifts → distinguish service fees (disclosure required) from small token gifts
  • Prior disclosure > subsequent disclosure

IV(C) Supervisory Responsibility

  • Supervisors have a duty to prevent subordinate violations
  • Must establish and enforce compliance procedures
  • Must take action upon discovering a violation
  • Cannot simply claim "I didn't know" as a defense

6. Standard V: Investment Analysis & Recommendations — Key Review

(Refer to L062 Comprehensive Review for details)

Sub-Standard One-Sentence Core
V(A) Analysis must have a reasonable basis
V(B) Material changes must be communicated to clients
V(C) Records must be retained for review

7. Cross-Standard Violation Analysis (Core Exam Topic)

7.1 Insider Information + Client Duties = ?

Scenario Standards Involved
Analyst receives MNPI, trades for clients before public disclosure II(A) + III(A)
Analyst receives MNPI, tells clients but does not trade personally II(A) still violated (causing others to trade)
Compliance learns of an employee using MNPI but takes no action IV(C) (supervisory failure)
Analyst does not trade but writes a report hinting at MNPI II(A) + V(B)

7.2 Employer Interests vs. Client Interests

Scenario Outcome
IBD pressures analyst to give a favorable rating to an IPO Analyst: I(B) Independence > IV(A) Employer loyalty
Analyst finds employer's product unsuitable for client but still recommends it III(B)/III(C) violation > beneficial to employer
Collecting client lists before departure to prepare for a new job IV(A) violation (client lists are employer property)

7.3 Independence + Suitability + Fair Dealing

Scenario Standards Involved
Investment banking client pressures for a favorable stock rating I(B) Independence
Recommended product does not match client's risk tolerance III(C) Suitability
Giving priority recommendations to large clients before small clients III(B) Fair Dealing

8. Mid-Assessment Questions (15 Questions)

Q1. Which of the following is NOT a criterion for determining whether information is "material"?

A) Whether a reasonable investor's decision would be affected by the information
B) Whether the information could cause a significant change in stock price
C) Whether the information is known to the company's CEO
D) Whether similar information has been considered material in the past


Q2. The correct understanding of the Mosaic Theory is:

A) Combining public information with non-material nonpublic information for analysis is legitimate
B) Combining public information with material nonpublic information for analysis is legitimate
C) All forms of information combination analysis should be prohibited
D) The Mosaic Theory applies only to institutional investors


Q3. An analyst discovers serious financial fraud in a stock recommended by the employer. The analyst should first:

A) Immediately sell the stock held personally
B) Contact regulators to report
C) Report through internal firm compliance procedures
D) Notify clients to sell immediately


Q4. A hedge fund manager simultaneously manages two accounts: a fund charging 2/20 and a separately managed account charging 1/10. In IPO allocation, the manager should:

A) Prioritize the higher-fee account
B) Prioritize long-term clients
C) Allocate fairly on a pro-rata basis
D) Allocate randomly


Q5. An analyst attends a luxury dinner organized by an issuer, valued at approximately $500. The correct approach is:

A) Decline or pay out of pocket to maintain independence
B) Accept but report to the employer
C) Accept and disclose in the research report
D) Accept but delay the next research report


Q6. A departing analyst takes a personally developed valuation model (created on company computers during work hours). This violates:

A) IV(A) — the model is employer property
B) V(C) — record retention
C) I(C) — misrepresentation
D) No violation; it is a personal work


Q7. An investment manager uses selective data in quarterly client reports, showing only profitable trades and omitting loss-making trades. This primarily violates:

A) III(A) — Loyalty
B) III(B) — Fair Dealing
C) III(D) — Performance Presentation
D) V(B) — Communication with Clients


Q8. Regarding the relationship between loyalty to employers (IV(A)) and loyalty to clients (III(A)):

A) Loyalty to employers always takes priority
B) Loyalty to clients always takes priority
C) Both exist in parallel; when they conflict, client interests take priority
D) Depends on the specific terms of the employment contract


Q9. An analyst learns from the CFO that the company is about to issue a profit warning (not yet public). The analyst should:

A) Immediately inform all clients of this information
B) Not trade, but hint to clients to watch out for risks
C) Not trade, not disseminate, report to compliance, and urge the company to disclose as soon as possible
D) Sell personal holdings


Q10. A supervisor discovers that a subordinate is suspected of insider trading but takes no action because the subordinate's performance is outstanding. The supervisor:

A) Has not violated — did not personally trade
B) Has not violated — it is unknown whether a violation actually occurred
C) Has violated IV(C) supervisory responsibility
D) Has only violated internal firm rules


Q11. Which of the following does NOT require the employer's written consent?

A) Accepting a $100 meal from a client
B) Accepting additional work-related compensation from a third party
C) Engaging in business that competes with the employer outside of work
D) Accepting "research sponsorship" from an issuer


Q12. GIPS (Global Investment Performance Standards) is an extension of which standard?

A) III(A)
B) III(C)
C) III(D)
D) V(A)


Q13. An analyst cites others' research in a report without attribution (for internal sharing only, not commercial use). This:

A) Is not a violation because it is for internal use
B) Violates I(C) — plagiarism
C) Violates V(A) — reasonable basis
D) Is not a violation as long as marked "for reference only"


Q14. Which of the following involves both II(A) and III(A) simultaneously?

A) An analyst selects a stock without conducting sufficient research
B) An analyst uses insider information to trade for client profit
C) An analyst recommends a stock after accepting kickbacks from the issuer
D) An analyst plagiarizes others' work in research


Q15. "As a CFA charterholder, you must comply with the strictest applicable rule." This principle originates from:

A) I(A) Knowledge of the Law
B) I(B) Independence & Objectivity
C) III(A) Loyalty
D) IV(A) Loyalty to Employer


9. Answer Key & Explanations

  1. C — Whether the CEO knows is not a legal criterion for "materiality." The key is the reasonable investor's perspective.
  2. A — Core of the Mosaic Theory: public information + non-material nonpublic information = legitimate analysis.
  3. C — Discovering problems with employer products should first go through internal compliance channels; bypassing the chain may cause the individual to violate rules before compliance approves.
  4. C — III(B) requires fair allocation; allocation cannot be determined by fee levels.
  5. A — $500 exceeds the acceptable range; best practice is to decline or pay out of pocket.
  6. A — Work completed using company resources (computers, work hours) belongs to the employer.
  7. C — Selective data presentation violates III(D)'s requirement for fair and complete performance presentation.
  8. C — Loyalty to employers cannot override loyalty to clients.
  9. C — Correct handling of MNPI: do not trade, do not disseminate, report to compliance, urge public disclosure.
  10. C — A supervisor's knowing inaction regarding subordinate violations is a direct violation of IV(C).
  11. A — Modest meals or entertainment do not trigger IV(B)'s written consent requirement.
  12. C — GIPS is a standardized extension of III(D) performance presentation standards.
  13. B — Plagiarism, whether public or internal, is an I(C) violation.
  14. B — Insider information = II(A); trading for clients = involves III(A) fiduciary duty.
  15. A — I(A) establishes the "strictest applicable standard" principle.

Next L065: Standard VI(A) — Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest

下一课:Standard VI(A):利益冲突披露

一、标准原文 · 二、核心解读 · 三、利益冲突的常见来源